In Two Days of Testimony, Generals Contradict Biden on Afghanistan Withdrawal Recommendations

September 30, 2021

Joint Chiefs Chair Gen. Mark Milley and Central Command head Kenneth McKenzie told lawmakers during two days of tense testimony that they had recommended that President Joe Biden keep a small number of troops in Afghanistan beyond the withdrawal deadline.

Milley and McKenzie testified Tuesday and Wednesday alongside Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin.

Milley and McKenzie both said they recommended that 2,500 service members stay behind to secure the area and support the Afghan military. Milley even said he thought troops could stay there “indefinitely.”

The views appear to contradict comments Biden made to ABC News before the withdrawal that no top generals advised maintaining a military presence in Afghanistan.

“Either the president lied to the American people, or he legitimately cannot remember the counsel of his top military advisors in winding down the longest war in American history, or you have not been fully accurate under oath,” Rep. Mike Johnson (R-La.) told the three leaders Wednesday, as The Hill noted.

The White House and some Biden backers, including House Armed Services Committee Chair Adam Smith (D-Wash.), have said Biden’s ABC News comments have been taken out of context, noting that he also said during the interview that his military advisors were “split” over the withdrawal.

“I want to remind everybody that the decision the president made was to stop fighting a war that after 20 years it was proven we could not win,” Smith said at Wednesday’s hearing. “There was no easy way to do that.”

DOD photo by Chad J. McNeeley

September 30, 2021

Recent News

Snap of the Week

Snap of the Week

Naval Academy plebes climb the Herndon Monument, a tradition symbolizing the successful completion of the midshipmen’s freshman year. The class of 2027 completed the climb in 2 hours, 19 minutes and 11 seconds. Navy photo by Stacy Godfrey

In Our Communities

In Our Communities

More than 74,000 residents of Whidbey Island, Washington could suffer long-term health impacts from the noise of jets stationed at Naval Air Station Whidbey Island, according to a University of Washington study, The Seattle Times reported. Researchers said the impact...

$2 Billion Aid Package Will Help Ukraine Build Its Own Weapons

$2 Billion Aid Package Will Help Ukraine Build Its Own Weapons

A new $2 billion aid package the State Department announced Thursday will help build a Ukraine Defense Enterprise Program, according to Defense News. The fund will help Ukraine buy weapons from other countries while “investing in Ukraine’s defense industrial base,...

NDAA Draft Asks for DOD Study on Privatizing Barracks

NDAA Draft Asks for DOD Study on Privatizing Barracks

The House Armed Services Committee’s draft National Defense Authorization Act indicates lawmakers may not be ready to privatize more barracks, as Military.com reported. “Members aren’t completely bought into privatizing all housing,” a senior Republican committee aide...

PAST STORIES